1858 REMINGTON for Sale
Browse 1858 remington listings from verified sellers across the U.S. on GunsAmerica.
Quick Look
The 1858 Remington is a cap-and-ball revolver originally developed during the American Civil War. Built for rugged reliability, it featured a solid frame and faster cylinder swapping compared to its contemporaries. Today, it remains popular with black powder enthusiasts and historical reenactors for its durability and realism.
Why It's a Top Choice
- Solid-frame design enhances strength and alignment
- Cylinder swap system faster than Colt's open-top models
- Popular with black powder shooters and reenactors
- Wide aftermarket support for barrels and grips
- Accurate sights for its era
Key Variants
1858 Remington New Model Army
Standard military issue revolver in .44 caliber, widely collected today.
1858 Remington Navy
Smaller .36 caliber version, favored for lighter recoil and compact size.
1858 Remington Carbine
Extended barrel carbine version, designed for mounted troops needing longer reach.
1858 Remington Stainless
Modern stainless steel reproductions for easier maintenance and longevity.
1858 Remington Conversion
Modified to fire metallic cartridges, ideal for post-Civil War cowboy action shooting.
Competitor Comparison Table
| Feature | 1858 Remington | Colt 1860 Army | Ruger Old Army |
|---|---|---|---|
| MSRP | $300–$600 (new reproductions) | $400–$800 (collector value varies) | $800–$1,200 (discontinued) |
| Capacity | 6 rounds | 6 rounds | 6 rounds |
| Weight | ~2.7 lbs | ~2.5 lbs | ~2.9 lbs |
| Optics Ready | No | No | No |
| Trigger Type | Single-action | Single-action | Single-action |
| Notable Pro | Quick-change cylinder system | Lighter and sleeker profile | Modern build quality, strongest frame |
| Notable Con | Slower to clean due to BP residue | Open-top design less robust | No longer in production |
Best Use Cases
- Black powder historical reenactment
- Traditional target shooting
- Collecting antique-style firearms
- Learning historical firearm platforms
- CAS (Cowboy Action Shooting) with BP divisions
FAQs
Can I use modern ammo in an 1858 Remington?
No, original models use black powder and cap-and-ball. Conversion cylinders allow metallic cartridges.
What is the effective range of the 1858 Remington?
Typical accuracy is good out to 50 yards, with skilled shooters reaching 75+ yards.
How does the cylinder swap system work?
Pins allow quick removal of the cylinder for fast reloading or preloaded replacements in battle.
Prefer nearby results? Toggle to search local listings.
Taylor's & Co. 1858 Remington Conversion
$1,199.99
Sign up for our newsletter
Frequently asked questions
What types of firearms does GunsAmerica offer online?
Are there any restrictions to buying legal firearms from GunsAmerica?
What are some of the best firearm companies available at GunsAmerica?
Can I sell my firearm to GunsAmerica?
How does GunsAmerica handle firearm shipping and transfers?
Who We Are
About
From the latest advancements in firearm technology to trusted essentials, GunsAmerica offers a comprehensive selection of gun accessories designed to enhance performance, reliability, and safety. Whether you need precision optics, durable stocks, high-capacity magazines, suppressors, or muzzle devices, our marketplace provides everything required to maintain, upgrade, and customize your firearms. We feature products from leading manufacturers, ensuring superior quality and compatibility across all firearm platforms. Our extensive inventory is built to support every shooter’s needs, from tactical applications and competitive shooting to hunting and everyday carry. At GunsAmerica, we are committed to delivering a seamless, secure shopping experience with competitive pricing, making it easier than ever to find the right accessories to optimize your firearms for any mission or environment.