Taylor’s & Company Model 1858 New Army .44-Caliber Black Powder Revolver:  Keeping the Legend Alive     

Cowboy Time Machine Handguns Historical Guns Mark Miller Misc. Pistols

Taylor's & Company Model 1858 New Army .44-Caliber Black Powder Revolver:  Keeping the Legend Alive     The cap and ball revolver, also known as the percussion revolver, is a sophisticated weapon of war. Even though those wars were in the 1800’s, the cap and ball remains an interesting and effective handgun. Taylor’s & Company is keeping these legends alive by producing classic firearms made famous by soldiers, cowboys, lawmen, and outlaws.

Until Samuel Colt, most pistols were single-shot muzzle-loaders fired by wheel lock, flintlock and percussion ignition systems. In 1835, Colt patented the first successful percussion revolver. After numerous designs, he came up with the 1836 Patterson revolver. Upgrades, modifications, better metallurgy and competitors soon followed.

Colt’s best customer was the Republic of Texas. The Texas army and navy placed orders Patterson revolvers. When the two military branches were disbanded, many of the five-shooters were given to the Rangers. The standard frontier gun at the time was the single shot flintlock muzzleloading Plains Rifle, a compact version of the Pennsylvania-Kentucky. Dependable and powerful, it was accurate to about two hundred yards. It took a full minute to load in a fight.

The Indians built their tactics around this weakness. They would send a few scouts to draw fire; then the entire war party would rush the Rangers during the reload. The Rangers carried pistols (often two or three) but single-shot flintlocks were inaccurate and unreliable. Indian bows and lances proved quick and deadly in close fights.

Taylor's & Company Model 1858 New Army .44-Caliber Black Powder Revolver:  Keeping the Legend Alive     

Texas Rangers with their cap and ball revolvers.

On June 8, 1844, Captain Jack Hays and fourteen Texas Rangers were on patrol looking for a Comanche war party who had conducted a series of raids near San Antonio. This patrol was different because Hays and his men were armed with recently obtained Patterson revolvers.

The Rangers encountered a Comanche war party of sixty warriors. The Comanches probed and taunted, advanced and withdrew. Then they attacked in mass. The Rangers stood back to back shooting and changing cylinders in their revolvers. When the fight at Walker’s Creek was over, the Rangers had lost one man (dead) and had four wounded.

The Comanches abandoned the field with their wounded leaving 23 dead warriors. This skirmish changed the fight in Texas and across the west. The repeating firearm made human wave attacks suicide.

The heart of the Colt design is a fixed barrel with a rotating cylinder drilled with five or six chambers (also known as charge holes).  Cap and ball pistols require loading loose powder and ball into each chamber. You dump in a measured powder charge, cover it with a ball and use the attached lever under the barrel of the gun to swage the ball into the cylinder.Taylor's & Company Model 1858 New Army .44-Caliber Black Powder Revolver:  Keeping the Legend Alive     

The rear of each chamber has a nipple which holds a percussion cap. When the hammer strikes the cap, a priming compound is ignited sending a jet of flame to the powder charge and propelling the ball down the barrel.  Although slow to reload, usually requiring three minutes, this method is simple and dependable.

You get six quick shots. You can reload, but it is going to take you some time unless you have another loaded cylinder. Sometimes caps will fail to fire or pieces of the cap from a previous shot can fall into the frame, binding the cylinder up so you can’t fire. Still, it was much better than a flintlock. Many fighters carried more than one handgun to make up in mass what they lacked in reload speed and reliability.Taylor's & Company Model 1858 New Army .44-Caliber Black Powder Revolver:  Keeping the Legend Alive     

These early revolvers were single action. The hammer had to be cocked before each round.  Colt devised a mechanical linkage which rotated the cylinder as the hammer was cocked. The only function performed by the trigger was to release the hammer. There was no safety, one chamber was normally left unloaded and the hammer lowered onto that chamber.

Loading under adverse conditions like wind and rain is problematic. During the Civil War, the US Army used paper cartridges, made in private and government-owned arsenals which made loading faster. They were simply inserted in the cylinder and then capped.

Colt’s 1836 patent expired in 1857 and Remington was waiting in the wings. Remington produced their Model 1858, a powerful and rugged revolver. Remarkably ahead of its time, the 1858 looks very much like a modern revolver.  It became famous in the Civil War as the Remington New Model Army,  a solid-frame design both elegant and reliable. The 1858 Remington was the first choice of officers following the Civil War.

Loaded with six 44 caliber bullets pushed by 30-35 grains of black powder, the New Model Army’s solid frame made it mechanically stronger than the Colts with modest recoil for its caliber. The groove and post sight system is better than the tiny Colt sights with a front bead sight and a notch in the hammer.  Easily removable, replaceable cylinders made reloading extremely fast.

I became infatuated with the New Model Army. The highly realistic Taylor’s & Company Model 1858 New Army .44-Caliber Black Powder Revolver was just what the doctor ordered. The beautiful blued steel frame is set off by a polished brass trigger guard. The octagonal barrel and walnut grips complete the authentic look.

Another cool thing about these guns is that you can buy them just like they did in 1858, no paperwork required. Just head down to the general store or Cabella’s and pick one up. You don’t have to fill out a form 4473 and there is no NICS check. State laws can be a different story. Some states exempt them entirely from firearms law like the federal government. Other states define them as guns.

There is an exception in federal firearms law for guns that were manufactured prior to 1898. It includes all replicas of those guns that do not use fixed ammunition such as cap & ball revolvers. The weapons of the Civil War and gunfighters like Wyatt Earp are not firearms according to ATFE. You can order them in the mail and get them delivered right to your door like pizza.

The 1858 New Army .44-Caliber Black Powder Revolver delivers that same power with its blued steel construction, polished brass trigger guard, octagonal barrel and walnut grips.


Manufacturer:   Uberti

Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price:   $347.00

Barrel Length:     8 Inch

Caliber: .44

Capacity:  6 rounds

Weight:  2.7 lbs

Sights:    Dovetail Front Blade

Overall Length:   13.6 Inches

Blue with steel frame and backstrap and brass trigger guard.

Six-shot. R&D Conversion Cylinder sold separately.

I didn’t get this thing to look at, the .44 is the most popular modern caliber for cap and ball. The .44 was adopted in the huge Army holster pistols of the Mexican War. The Navy went with the more elegant .36 caliber, but the Army didn’t just shoot people, they had to stop horses too.

These bullets can be pushed past 1,000 feet per second. Like most cap and ball revolvers, the .44 caliber is plenty accurate. Pistols like the big Colt Walker and Dragoon series of pistols are available, but the later service guns, particularly the more sophisticated Remington New Model Army caught my eye.

After the Civil War, Colt and Smith and Wesson introduced cartridge firing revolvers. Even though outdated, the old cap and ball revolvers remained popular with former soldiers. Bill Cody kept his Remington cap and ball revolver well into the 1900’s; he said that it never failed him.

Many of these old veterans were converted to fire metallic cartridges, but in the 1870s and 1880s, as more convenient cartridge revolvers were introduced, they lost popularity. Many percussion pistols were converted to fire cartridges using conversion cylinders and these are still available today.

You can switch back and forth from black powder to centerfire by simply changing the cylinder. The conversion cylinder holds the cartridges in six chambers covered by a plate. The parts fit together without screws or threads, so reloading is simple: pull the cylinder pin, drop the cylinder and lift off the plate.Taylor's & Company Model 1858 New Army .44-Caliber Black Powder Revolver:  Keeping the Legend Alive     

Taylor’s and Company makes cartridge cylinders that fit the 1858 Remington and many other cap & ball pistols. Certified 4150 arsenal-grade steel is used in the production of these cylinders and top-plates. These units are safe and durable but you should only use lead cowboy ammunition that doesn’t exceed 850 FPS. No frame modification is needed, although minor fitting may be required due to gun manufacturer variations.

Cylinders ship separate from a pistol purchase. If you put one of these cylinders into a cap and ball pistol, you are, according to federal law, manufacturing a firearm. State laws may vary and the gun may have to be registered. If you can’t own a handgun legally you cannot manufacture one legally.

The Taylor’s and Company Conversion Cylinder for Pietta 1858 Remington Steel Frame, .44 Caliber in a Blued finish list for $240.Taylor's & Company Model 1858 New Army .44-Caliber Black Powder Revolver:  Keeping the Legend Alive     

While cap and ball pistols may seem primitive, at close range they are just as deadly as a phaser.  They are effective and powerful weapons of war, ask the Comanche. While actual pistols from this era exist, they are far too valuable to shoot and there are safety concerns.

Modern replicas are affordable high-quality replicas of those classic guns. Taylor’s & Company carry the largest selection of black powder revolvers on the market.  They cover every significant firearm model from the 1847 Walker to the 1873 Peacemaker.

Taylor’s & Company’s faithful reproductions of 19th century Civil War and Old West guns are made using precision machinery and high-quality materials. If you want to test your mettle against the Union Army or the old west gunfighters, Taylor’s and Company is your huckleberry.

Visit Taylor’s & Company by clicking here.

***Shop GunsAmerica for your next Taylor’s & Co pistol***





Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • John Wilmes February 18, 2024, 5:41 pm

    Loved the article, my hat is off to you and Thank you for your service to our country Mark Miller

  • James May 24, 2020, 7:48 pm

    One comment early in the article concerning the muzzle-loading plains type rifle was the that it took “a full minute to load in a fight.” That is just plain wrong!

    It MAY take a “full minute” to load IF you take your time and do everything single handed such as pouring powder from container to measure, then from measure to bore and cutting each patch at the muzzle and passing each article to and from pouch or table… Yeah, that MIGHT take a minute. But, with a loading block with patched balls ready to load or even just pre-cut and lubed patches, and being in a hurry, a sustained rate of 2 shots a minute would be the norm.

    People who make flat statements in articles they write should take care to research what they are writing about.

    To further illustrate my point; “In a fight,” one might just put the ball down the bore and thump the butt on the ground to seat the ball, not bothering with the rammer, three shots a minute is very possible. Now, this last method I described is not to be used at all these days. It is fool hardy and dangerous. Pouring powder straight from horn or flask can bring about a container explosion right in front of your face. Not properly seating the ball by ramming can produce a bulged or burst barrel! I only mentioned it because, historically speaking, it was preferable to facing a charging Comanche with a half loaded or empty rifle!

    Now, that Native Americans would take advantage of reloading times is quite true. They were nobody’s dummies and war was, especially for the Comanches, their favorite past time! With that in mind, experienced rangers or “Indian fighters” always took care that some one or more held back a loaded rifle in case of just such a rush. But, inexperienced settlers or such like might not be so knowledgeable or disciplined enough to do that.

    I make these statements from being a long student of history, and especially so of Texas where I live, and from shooting black powder muzzle loading rifles and pistols since I was 16. That event was nearly 50 years ago now. As a Civil War reenactor, I was able to manage 4 aimed shots a minute with paper cartridges and a P1853 Enfield rifle though admittedly, not consistently. (I am talking about live fire exercises and not shooting blanks.)

  • ejharb August 27, 2018, 10:52 pm

    If I had to go cap and ball it’d be a steel frame 1858.to me a far superior weapon to any pre 1873 colt.

  • interventor July 17, 2018, 4:36 pm

    Those anticipating long gun fights, such as the military, carried multiple loaded cylinders, including the percussion caps. Exchanging loaded cylinders was much faster than reloading the cylinder, obviously. I’ve seen Civil War containers for up to 18 cylinders.

  • Bill Ricks July 9, 2018, 10:40 am

    What cartridge does the extra cylinder shoot??

    • Sgt. Pop July 9, 2018, 12:18 pm

      The .44 conversion cylinder handles the .45 Colt (ok, LONG colt) and or the .45 Scofield which is a tad shorter. My Mod. 60 Colt conversions use the .45 Scofield but I need to trim back the .45 Colt case a little to use the bullets I like to use. The .36 conversions shoot the .38.

    • Scott Crockett July 9, 2018, 2:53 pm

      They are available in .45 Colt or .45 ACP.

      • srsquidizen July 10, 2018, 4:53 pm

        I was wondering about the 45 ACP.

        Cylinders for .45 COLT that I’m familiar with recommend ONLY mild-mannered “Cowboy Action” loads rated 850 fps or less with plain old lead (non-jacketed) bullets. That’s easy to find in 45 Colt, but I’ve never seen factory Cowboy Action in 45 ACP. Even cheapo range stuff has got to be a pretty stout load or it ain’t gonna cycle the 1911’s and such that 45 ACP usually goes into. Is that 45 ACP cylinder just for DIY ammo loaders or what?

  • Todd July 9, 2018, 10:08 am

    Pretty package.
    Any idea where they are manufactured?


    • Scott Crockett July 9, 2018, 2:53 pm
    • Mark N. July 17, 2018, 12:40 am

      Italy for Uberti, Pietta. Pedersoli makes high quality reproduction cartridge rifles. Uberti I believe has started issuing Springfileds and a few other Civil War rifled muskets, as well as a line of Winchester repeating rifles and Sharps trap door carbines.

  • akjc77 July 9, 2018, 9:32 am

    Has anybody ever seen jump fire on a black power revolver? I’ve heard so many stories of how loading without grease can create the fire to jump from one load to another while shooting? That just scares me to think about!

    • Cary Kieffer July 9, 2018, 10:40 am

      Chain fire is more likely to happen from loose fitting caps than from the front if the cylinder. This has been slow motion video’d to prove it more than likely will happen from caps. I shoot an 1860 Colt Army and a couple of 1847 Colt Walkers all the time. Never a problem…a properly sized ball will leave a tiny lead ring that falls away after seating it. It’s pretty tight…loose caps, that’s where it’s at in my opinion. Still, never happened to me in all this time and I’ve never seen it either. Just stories…lol, ya know how stories are. Dont let it scare you, just follow the rules and use common sense and B.P. guns are a great hobby. I buy higher quality aftermarket nipples and use the nipple people’s recommended caps. In my case #11’s. Track of the Wolf is the nipple place. It’s a harder, more precise nipple than say Uberti puts in their guns. Good snug fit and you’ll be just fine.

      Next on my list is a flintlock, the 1766 French musket that was the first official issue to the Continental Marines. Semper fi.

    • Scott Crockett July 9, 2018, 2:55 pm

      It won’t happen if you use the correct size ball or bullet. I also cap my cylinders with a bore lube for added protection.

  • Luke July 9, 2018, 7:40 am

    Want one!

Send this to a friend